Trends · data through September 2026

Insurance trends in New York

Iceflower tracks 107 stores from 87 insurance chains in New York.

Rankings come from real card and bank transactions across a panel of 130M+ US and EU consumers. We publish relative growth and rankings, never revenue figures. About the data

Tracked chains
87
Tracked stores
107
Consumer panel
130M+

Growth ranking

Fastest-growing tracked insurance chains

Ranked by year-over-year growth of share of tracked local spend. Arrows show movement in the rankings since last year. Each dot in the chart is one tracked chain: bigger market position to the right, faster growth higher up, more tracked stores in a bigger dot. Colors match the store map below. Farmers Insurance and AAA sit in the high-growth half.

# Chain YoY growth
RankChainRank movementYoY growth
1 F Farmers Insurance logo Farmers Insurance - -3.1%
2 A AAA logo AAA - -7.8%
  • Insurance agencies
  • Auto & Home Insurance
  • Auto Clubs & Roadside
  • Health & Medicare Plans
  • Life Insurance & Final Expense
  • Business Insurance
  • Other categories

Store footprint

Store map

107 tracked store locations in New York, colored by category.

  • Insurance agencies (64)
  • Auto & Home Insurance (21)
  • Auto Clubs & Roadside (15)
  • Health & Medicare Plans (4)
  • Life Insurance & Final Expense (2)
  • Business Insurance (1)
  • Other categories

Top tracked chains by store count

  • 1 A AAA logo AAA 15
  • 2 F Farmers Insurance logo Farmers Insurance 4
  • 3 F Freeway Insurance logo Freeway Insurance 3
  • 4 S State Farm logo State Farm 2
  • 5 P Precise Leads 1
  • 6 T TIAA logo TIAA 1
  • 7 L Long Island Farm Bureau 1
  • 8 L Lindsey Giagni 1
  • 9 H Hoselton Agency 1
  • 10 M MVP Health Care 1
  • 11 E Experior Financial Group logo Experior Financial Group 1
  • 12 P Pine Bush Agents 1
  • 13 C Cardinal Agency 1
  • 14 C Commercial Coverage 1
  • 15 B Brockport Auto Insurance 1
  • 16 J Jeffrey Sachs 1
  • 17 S Status Agency 1
  • 18 T Tompkins Glen A Inc 1
  • 19 C Christina Lloyd 1
  • 20 A Alexander Yu 1
  • 21 D Denied 1
  • 22 N Native American 1
  • 23 S Scott Beatty 1
  • 24 T The Guardian 1
  • 25 R Rinker Agency LLC 1
  • 26 O Oswego County Mutual Insurance 1
  • 27 M Merchants Insurance Group logo Merchants Insurance Group 1
  • 28 N Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company logo Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company 1
  • 29 E Excellus BlueCross BlueShield logo Excellus BlueCross BlueShield 1
  • 30 B Bankers Life logo Bankers Life 1
  • 31 G Gladys Quinones 1
  • 32 G Global Coverage, Inc. 1
  • 33 M Molina Healthcare of New York logo Molina Healthcare of New York 1
  • 34 L Lone Star Brokerage Inc 1
  • 35 A Allstate logo Allstate 1
  • 36 B Broadview Insurance Agency 1
  • 37 A American National logo American National 1
  • 38 M MetLife logo MetLife 1
  • 39 G GEICO Insurance Agent logo GEICO Insurance Agent 1
  • 40 H Humana logo Humana 1
  • 41 L La Casa De Los Seguros 1
  • 42 N New York Life Insurance logo New York Life Insurance 1
  • 43 C Christopher Shafer 1
  • 44 V Virginia Chan 1
  • 45 M Michael Casseri 1
  • 46 M Mid-Hudson VIP 1
  • 47 P Pearland Brokerage 1
  • 48 W Willoughby Insurance 1
  • 49 O Ontario Insurance Company 1
  • 50 T The Hartford logo The Hartford 1

More trends

Ready to see your market clearly?

Create an account, pick a plan, and explore your merchants, competitors and customers the way they actually behave.

Working in insurance? See consumer transaction data for insurance →