Trends · data through July 2026

Second Hand Shops in Indianapolis-Carmel-Greenwood, IN

Iceflower tracks 76 stores from 37 second hand shops chains in Indianapolis-Carmel-Greenwood, IN. Goodwill grew fastest over the last year, ahead of Plato's Closet and Habitat for Humanity ReStore.

Rankings come from real card and bank transactions across a panel of 130M+ US and EU consumers. We publish relative growth and rankings, never revenue figures. About the data

Tracked chains
37
Tracked stores
76
Consumer panel
130M+

Growth ranking

Fastest-growing tracked second hand shops chains

Ranked by year-over-year growth of share of tracked local spend. Arrows show movement in the rankings since last year. Each dot in the chart is one tracked chain: bigger market position to the right, faster growth higher up, more tracked stores in a bigger dot. Colors match the store map below. Goodwill and Plato's Closet sit in the high-growth half.

# Chain YoY growth
RankChainRank movementYoY growth
1 G Goodwill logo Goodwill - -0.9%
2 P Plato's Closet logo Plato's Closet - -15.8%
3 H Habitat for Humanity ReStore logo Habitat for Humanity ReStore - -67.1%
  • Goodwill
  • St. Vincent de Paul
  • EZPAWN
  • Plato's Closet
  • Amanda's Exchange
  • La Villita Mega Mall
  • Earl's Auction Company
  • Other tracked chains

Store footprint

Store map

76 tracked store locations in Indianapolis-Carmel-Greenwood, IN. The 7 largest tracked chains are highlighted.

  • Goodwill (34)
  • St. Vincent de Paul (1)
  • EZPAWN (2)
  • Plato's Closet (4)
  • Amanda's Exchange (1)
  • La Villita Mega Mall (1)
  • Earl's Auction Company (1)
  • Other tracked chains

Top tracked chains by store count

  • 1 G Goodwill logo Goodwill 34
  • 2 P Plato's Closet logo Plato's Closet 4
  • 3 H Habitat for Humanity ReStore logo Habitat for Humanity ReStore 3
  • 4 E EZPAWN logo EZPAWN 2
  • 5 S St. Vincent de Paul 1
  • 6 T The Scrounge Around 1
  • 7 N Newman & Co. logo Newman & Co. 1
  • 8 C Consigned by Design 1
  • 9 S Selective Seconds Consignment 1
  • 10 E Emporium 1101 1
  • 11 T Traderbaker Flea Market 1
  • 12 B Broad Ripple Vintage 1
  • 13 A AACT Flea Market 1
  • 14 S Style Threads Resale & Boutique 1
  • 15 S Shadeland Peddlers Flea Market 1
  • 16 M Me & My Sisters Flea Market 1
  • 17 H Hancock Hope House Inc 1
  • 18 T The Lord's Cupboard 1
  • 19 G Grace Thrift Store logo Grace Thrift Store 1
  • 20 C Cancer Association of Shelby County 1
  • 21 B Beyond The Thrift 1
  • 22 A Amanda's Exchange 1
  • 23 L La Villita Mega Mall 1
  • 24 E Earl's Auction Company logo Earl's Auction Company 1
  • 25 E Emporium 40 1
  • 26 E Emporium 31 1
  • 27 C Cash America Pawn 1
  • 28 W Whale of a Sale Columbus 1
  • 29 W Wheeler Mission Store logo Wheeler Mission Store 1
  • 30 U Uptown Cheapskate logo Uptown Cheapskate 1
  • 31 T Treasures Indoor Flea Market & Consignment 1
  • 32 T Thrifty Threads 1
  • 33 I Indy Pawn 1
  • 34 H Here We Grow Again Kids Consignment Sale logo Here We Grow Again Kids Consignment Sale 1
  • 35 T Trader Bucks 1
  • 36 T The Toggery Resale Boutique 1
  • 37 P Peddlers Mall 1

More trends

Ready to see your market clearly?

Create an account, pick a plan, and explore your merchants, competitors and customers the way they actually behave.